Chuck steak and chuck roast are both cuts of beef taken from a cow. Both actually happen to come from the same region of the cow, as well. Both chuck steak and chuck roast come cut from the shoulder of the cow. Despite this, there are many subtle differences between chuck steak and chuck roast that people should know about. From cooking instructions to tenderness to appearance, these two cuts of beef have a lot of unique traits.
Chuck Roast vs. Chuck Steak: The Main Differences Explained
While chuck roast and chuck steak are both cut from the shoulder area of the cow their size is different with chuck roast being a tick cut that's well-marbled and large enough to serve to multiple people. By contrast, chuck steak is a thinner slice.
These size differences mean chuck roast is ideal for slow, moist cooking methods while chuck steak can be grilled or broiled, especially if it has been tenderized or marinated. Both steaks have tough fibers that need to be broken down in their cooking process.
Finally, chuck roast is used in different dishes that include stews and pot roasts while chuck steaks can be used for dishes like fajitas or stir-frys in addition. Let's examine each cut of beef in more detail.
What is Chuck Roast?
Chuck roast is the chuck portion of the cow. This is cut from the shoulder region. Due to the area of the cow from which it's cut, there's not much fat or marbling on it. Cows get a ton of movement and exercise to their shoulders, therefore, there's far less fat than other parts of their body. However, due to this, chuck portions of meat tend to be much tougher.
What is Chuck Steak?
Chuck streak is a portion of the chuck that is cut away from the chuck roast itself. It's a smaller portion of meat cut off to create a smaller steak. It's not very tender, but can sometimes give off the same flavor as a ribeye. Many people call the chuck steak the “poor man's ribeye” because it happens to be far less expensive than a ribeye would be in the grocery store. While it is inexpensive, it's also flavorful, as well.
Chuck roast and chuck steak have different uses in the kitchen when cooking. Due to the size of a chuck roast, it's used for many different types of roasts, such as pot roast, and stews. This is because many people slow-cook the meat when using it. It's extremely thick and flavorful, which is given off in the crockpot process or slow cooker.
Chuck steak is used instead for a steak dinner mostly, or it can be cut up and used in other recipes. It's an inexpensive steak to buy and cook; as such, many people also use chuck steak for pot pies and ground beef, as well.
While chuck steaks are often cut from chuck roasts, the two can have different flavor palettes. It depends on how they are being cooked. Many people opt to use a cast iron to pan-sear a chuck steak, which will give it a smokey flavor. On the contrary, slow-cooking a chuck roast will give it a completely different flavor palette than a pan-seared chuck steak. However, the beefy flavor of both remains the same in each dish.
Calories and Fat
When it comes to the nutritional values of chuck steaks and chuck roasts, this also depends on what you are using the beef for. Different recipes will have different calories, depending on what sauces and additives you cook. Overall, a 3-ounce cut of cooked chuck roast usually contains around 250-300 calories. The biggest difference in calories and fat between chuck roasts and chuck steaks comes down to size, as well. Chuck roasts are bigger portions because they are mostly in pot roasts and other recipes where the beef is in abundance. Chuck steaks are smaller and have a smaller calorie count.
Chuck roasts and chuck steaks tend to cost around the same, but chuck steaks can be slightly more expensive than chuck roasts. This is simply due to the labor of cutting the steaks by the butcher. However, both cuts are extremely affordable in comparison to other cuts of beef, such as ribeyes and tenderloins.
Which to Buy
- Chuck steak is often eaten on its own, but it can be cut or ground up to be used in recipes. Meanwhile, a chuck roast is often used for various roasts and stews.
- A chuck steak is generally pan-seared in a cast iron skillet, while a chuck roast is often slow-cooked. Slow-cooking a chuck roast will ensure it reaches ideal tenderness and flavor.
- While they are generally around the same price, chuck steak can be slightly more expensive than chuck roast.
When it comes down to it, if you're on the fence between a chuck roast and a chuck steak, it all depends on what kind of recipe you are going to make. If you're going to make something such as a stew or a roast for your whole family, a chuck roast is the better choice. But, if you want to make something that's leaner, smaller, and more of a steak, clearly the chuck steak is the better option.
Try this delicious chuck roast recipe:Print
1 (3 pound) chuck roast
1 can stewed tomatoes (16 ounces)
1 Tablespoon mustard
1/2 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce
1/4 cup water
1 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon black pepper
1 teaspoon thyme
1 teaspoon rosemary
1 teaspoon basil
2 cloves garlic, minced
4 potatoes, thickly sliced
3 carrots, cut into chunks
2 onions ,chopped
3 ribs celery, sliced
1. In the bottom of a crockpot add the juice of the canned tomatoes. Set the stewed tomatoes aside for step 4.
2. Add mustard, Worcestershire sauce, water, salt, pepper, thyme, rosemary, and basil.
3. Add the minced garlic.
4. Next add potatoes, the reserved stewed tomatoes, carrots, onion and celery. Rub roast with salt and pepper and place on top of the vegetables in the crock pot.
5. Cook on low for 7 to 8 hours, until all vegetables are tender and meat is no longer red inside.