The 11 Best Consignment Shops in Evansville, Indiana

Evansville, IN, is a dynamic city known as a tourist hotspot. In Evansville, guests can enjoy the riverfront, the amazing Mesker Park Zoo, and more. Additionally, this city is relatively large, with approximately 116,486 people living here. With the size of Evansville and many tourist attractions, it is no surprise that it has many unique consignment shops for guests to peruse. This list contains the top consignment shops in Evansville, IN. However, this list is not exhaustive! There are many more shops to check out if you are in the area. You can start with these fantastic stores. However, if you are searching for the perfect consignment shop, remember there are numerous more to try out. There are many places to browse while in Evansville. 

Now, let's look at the top consignment shops in Evansville, IN.

1. Camilla's Closet

1330 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715

Camilla's Closet is a large consignment store offering shoppers a wide range of categories, whether you are shopping for infants clothing, handbags, or jewelry. Camilla's Closet also has a special jewelry section with Curt the Jewelry, focusing on multiple areas, including customizing jewelry and repair. 

Among the accolades this consignment shop has earned include winning Number One Platinum in Best Consignment Shop/ Resale Store and Where to Buy Clothes for Women in 2019. In 2021, Camilla's Closet was also awarded the Best Boutique, making it an excellent place to find unique items. 

2. Style Encore Evansville

833 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715

If you are a woman looking for must-have trendy clothing and accessories, stopping by Style Encore in Evansville is a great way to spend the afternoon. This consignment shop buys and sells women's clothing, including business attire and accessories like purses. If you are looking for name-brand items, you may find the best pair of jeans or tops for much less than the retail price! 

When selling to Style Encore, you will receive cash immediately for the desired items. These items should be in excellent condition; if they are designer, that's a plus! Additionally, Style Encore has an online store that makes shopping right from the comfort of your home easy.

3. World Wide Missions Consignment 

301 N Congress Ave, Evansville, IN 47715

World Wide Missions Consigment is a large shop with various products ranging from decor and seasonal clothing to toys. 

What's also unique about World Wide Missions is they host free days, where they place items in their parking lot for free, impacting their surrounding community and helping sustainability. 

4. Molly's Upscale Consignment Boutique

5600 E Virginia St, Evansville, IN 47715

Molly's Upscale Consignment Boutique began in 2000 to offer the community a place to buy and sell gently used name-brand and designer clothes and accessories. 

One attribute that makes Molly's Upscale Consignment Boutique stand out is that it offers possible home visits. In addition, this boutique buys and sells designer products, which include Gucci, Prada, and Louis Vuitton. 

5. Kids Consignment LLC

4201 Hogue Rd, Evansville, IN 47712

Every parent knows that kids grow out of their clothes and shoes at a record pace. This can make shopping for new clothes a pain! Therefore, having a place to go to find great quality items without breaking the bank is a must for many parents. Kids Consignment LLC is a well-organized, clean, and spacious place for parents to find what they need, regardless of their child's age. 

6. AnnaLe's Twice Chosen Bridal & Prom Consignment Shop

Suite 1110, Washington Square, Evansville, IN 47715

If you want the perfect wedding or prom dress, stop by AnnaLe's Twice Chosen Bridal & Prom Consignment Shop. This shop has been open for 32 years and prides itself on offering quality service to those searching for the perfect dress. 

Walking into AnnaLe's Twice Chosen, you will find more than just prom and wedding dresses. They offer numerous items, including purses, tiaras, veils, and jewelry. 

Also, if you want to sell your items to this boutique, there are a few essential details to keep in mind. The dresses and items cannot be older than three years, should be in excellent condition, and you do not have to have an appointment to bring your items in. 

7. AbyssCo

4597 Washington Ave, Evansville, IN 47715

AbyssCo is a clothing consignment shop described as “cool” and “fun” by many reviewers. 

The items they sell range from home decor to clothing. Whether you are looking for an item that is a bit funky or something to complete your traditional outfit, AbyssCo is a delightful place to shop. Not to mention, the store has its very own shop cat, so be sure to stop in and say hi!

8. Seek And Find Consignments 

4512 N First Ave, Evansville, IN 47710

Seek and Find Consignments focuses on home decor and furniture. Therefore, if you are looking for that perfect decoration to complete your kitchen or living room style, visiting Seek And Find Consignment may bring you face-to-face with the one! 

The store is very large, with 14,000 square feet of shop space. 

New arrivals come to the shop often, and products are marked down every thirty days. Therefore, if you have your eye on a specific item, it may mark down sooner rather than later. However, items constantly sell, so do not wait too long if you find the ideal piece! 

9. Karen's Upscale Resale Furniture 

1324 N Fares Ave, Evansville, IN 47711

One reviewer describes Karen's Upscale Resale Furniture as “stepping into a big fancy house.” if you are looking for genuinely incredible upscale pieces, try this shop first. The pieces are considered high quality and reasonably priced, and the customer service is top-notch! This store has everything you would want in a consignment shop. 

10. Plato's Closet Evansville 

673 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715

Plato's Closet is a well-known consignment chain that buys and sells gently used clothing. You do not have to have an appointment to bring your items here. Plato's Closet buys designer items, including clothes, jewelry, shoes, and accessories. These items should be in excellent condition. Additionally, Plato's Closet will pay right on the spot for the items. 

You can look on the Plato's Closet website for items they are searching for. These products are typically in style and trending right now. If you are looking for designer items at an affordable price, Plato's Closet is a great place to try out first. 

11. Back Porch Consignments 

4005 E Eichel Ave, Evansville, IN 47715

Back Porch Consignments is the place to shop when it comes to finding the perfect knick-knack you didn't know you needed. 

The customer service is top-notch and helpful, and the products are of excellent quality, making this a fun place to shop. 

One Last Note

Regardless of what items you are searching for, there are many excellent consignment shops in Evansville, IN. Whether looking for the perfect prom dress, designer purses, or antique knick-knacks, you may find your next priceless treasure in these one-of-a-kind stores! 

The image featured at the top of this post is ©Vergani Fotografia/Shutterstock.com.