I Used to Love Crumbl Cookies, But These 14 Alternatives Are Cheaper and Better

It's no secret that most kids love cookies. If our family could eat them for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, we would. For many years, my kids and I used to love Crumbl Cookies. They have a great variety and fun flavors. However, they can also be a bit costly, so we started looking elsewhere. Luckily, we have found many other cookie brands that are just as tasty and a bit more affordable.

Crumbl Cookies has only been around since 2017, when Jason McGowan and Sawyer Hemsley opened the first location in Logan, UT. There are now over 1,000 locations across the U.S., and since 2017, the co-founders have turned their fun side hustle into a business that brings in $1 billion a year.

Despite the following that Crumbl Cookies has, some have criticized the chain, often calling it overrated and overpriced. Or, in the case of this article from The Washington Post, overhyped and underbaked.

Regardless of how you feel about Crumbl, there may come a time when you look for an alternative that has tasty, more affordable cookies. There's a lot out there to choose from, from the big companies like Tiff's Treats to the smaller companies, such as Taylor Chip. Check out this list and see if you find your new favorite. 

This post was updated in August 2025 to include updated information about Crumbl Cookies and additional editorial advancements.

It usually only takes one trip to discover that you love Crumbl Cookies. The key to their success is the incredible variety. They have cookies that look like they came out of Willy Wonka's factory. The company began in 2017, and they've become a hit ever since.

Although they originally sold only chocolate chip cookies, some of the new cookie flavors include wild berry sugar, cookies and cream, cookies with Lucky Charms on top, and more. As far as price, a typical large cookie will cost about $5, but the prices go up when you order larger packages.

Here's a look at some of the other tasty alternatives if you're looking for a new cookie place to visit.

The brand Love & Cookies separates itself by being a gourmet cookie company that sends out high-quality frozen cookie dough to customers so they can make it at home. This company was founded in 2021. Yes, you have to do some of the work, but the flavors are amazing and include triple chocolate, M&M with chocolate chip, and many gluten-free options. As far as price, a typical bag will cost $14, but you get many cookies out of that bag of dough.

One of the most reliable cookie products in the market is Tiff's Treats, which has been around for 26 years. The company is very similar to Crumbl Cookies because they sell brownies, truffles, cookies, and more. They sell several tasty and traditional flavors, including snickerdoodle, white chip almond, and oatmeal raisin. They also sell birthday baskets and other fun items. As far as cost, the cookies are comparable to Crumbl Cookies.

Another competitor to try if you love Crumbl Cookies is Fancypants Baking Co. This company is 21 years old, and its main business is selling tasty cookies. What really sets this cookie shop apart is the fact that they use upcycled ingredients, so they help the planet while providing tasty treats. They have all the classic flavors, including ginger snap and chocolate chip. The cost is usually around $30 a bag, but they often have coupons.

When it comes to cookies, ice cream, and other tasty treats, you can't go wrong with Dairy Queen. It's hard to believe that this tasty brand has been around for 85 years. While they are more known for their Blizzard treats, the company does sell cookies, including their amazing fudge-stuffed cookie. Prices at Dairy Queen continue to be affordable. You can get many of their treats for $5 or so.

Great American Cookies has been around for 48 years, and they're still making a splash to this day. The company sells cookies, cookie cakes, icing-topped cookies, and more. They have a variety of tasty flavors, including chocolate chip and other classics. One of their most beloved desserts is the Double Doozies, which are two cookies with a ton of tasty icing in the middle. As far as cost, the company offers a great bargain. One cookie will cost you about $3, and the packages go up from there.

Proving that there's something for everyone, we have Sweet Loren's. Like Crumbl Cookies, they make tasty desserts. The difference here is that everything is vegan and gluten-free. They're also made with non-GMO ingredients, so you can satisfy your sweet tooth without worrying about what you're eating. They have a ton of amazing flavors, and you get a great deal. You can get six cases of cookies for about $60.

Cookies By Design is another cookie company that does things a bit differently. This business creates and sells colorful frosted sugar cookies. They're the type that you often see at birthday parties or handed out on special occasions. Cookies By Design offers a variety of flavors, including oatmeal raisin and chocolate chip. When you order, you'll typically need to order a full batch, and the costs typically start around $40.

One of the biggest competitors is also a great go-to if you love Crumbl Cookies. The idea for Insomnia Cookies was created in a dorm room in 2003. Now, the company is owned by Krispy Kreme, and they have over 200 locations. The company sells a variety of treats, including brownies, deluxe cookies, and blondies. You can get a variety pack of 16 cookies for close to $25, so it's a better deal than Crumbl Cookies.

If you've loved cookies for a long time, then you're likely familiar with Mrs. Fields. They debuted way back in 1977, and their cookies are just as good today as they were back then. The company separates itself by using high-quality ingredients and making classic cookies like oatmeal raisin, walnut, and white chocolate macadamia. You can get many of their cookie packages for under $30.

Many cookie lovers have heard of Milk Bar, and many consider the brand to be their favorite. The brand makes individually wrapped cookies, truffles, cakes, and pies. Milk Bar is considered to be New York's finest bakery, but they sell and ship all over the nation. Some of their classic flavors include blueberry, chocolate confetti, triple peanut butter, and more. You can get a tin of cookies for around $30.

Of all the brands on this list, perhaps the most similar to Crumbl Cookies is Dirty Dough. Like their competitor, Dirty Dough makes wild cookies with a variety of toppings and fillings. Check out their site to see all of their outrageous flavors, which include grasshopper pie, red velvet, coconut cream pie, and classics like chocolate chip. As far as cost, you can get a single cookie for $5.

Chip City is a cookie company out of New York and New Jersey. However, you can have the cookies delivered nationwide. The company is famous for its abundance of flavors. At any given time, the company has up to 40 different flavors up for grabs, plus seasonal treats. If you're hungry, the cookies cost around $7 or more for different packages.

If you're looking for something a bit edgier, then Cookie Plug may be for you. Their unique angle is making tasty cookies that have an urban or graffiti-like appearance. They have many fun flavors, including Pixie Junkie Sugar Cookie and Bam Bam Fruity Cereal. They also have keto-friendly flavors, including Calvin Snickerdoodle and Black Magic Chocolate. You can get a package of 12 cookies for $20 and up.

Finally, if you love Crumbl Cookies, then you'll love the melt-in-your-mouth flavors of Taylor Chip. This company was founded by a husband and wife team, and the brand has since exploded. At this time, they produce over 20 different types of cookies, plus gluten-free and vegan options. Flavors include everything from peanut butter and jelly to chocolate chip. The prices are a bit higher. A box of 12 cookies can cost close to $50 or up.