Why Some Kids Have ‘Food Phases’—and What Parents Can Learn from It

Your child may be obsessed with carrots—cooked carrots, raw carrots, carrots with ranch, or even just carrots on their own. Then suddenly, one day, it all changes: “I HATE CARROTS!” How can you navigate these food phases without throwing away mountains of food your child once loved?

Whether it's a sudden aversion to previously loved foods, stubbornness during mealtime, or an overwhelming reluctance to try anything new, these challenges can leave parents feeling frustrated and helpless. It often seems like you're stuck in a cycle of wasted food and emotional battles at the dinner table, creating a stressful environment for both you and your child.

Even when it seems hopeless, remember that many families have navigated these turbulent waters of food phases and emerged with positive outcomes. Understanding that this phase is a common part of childhood development can provide reassurance. It’s important to recognize that children are constantly learning about their preferences, and their tastes can change frequently. To shed more light on this topic, we spoke with a pediatric dietitian to learn more about how to move past these phases.

Understanding Food Phases

To learn more about why children go through food phases, we turn to Katharine Jeffcoat, RDN, LD, pediatric dietitian and owner of NW Pediatric & Family Nutrition. She provides insights into the different aspects of food phases that children experience.

According to Jeffcoat, the various phases of eating that children go through are often closely tied to their cognitive development. “It is very common for all kids to go through these stages,” she explains.

Jeffcoat says that around 1 to 2 years of age, children become more self-aware, recognizing themselves as individuals. During this stage, they often reject being spoon-fed and seek greater independence in feeding themselves. She says this period also coincides with heightened sensory sensitivity, a protective mechanism that helps prevent young children from ingesting harmful substances. Jeffcoat notes, “However, this same sensitivity can also cause them to reject foods they previously ate as babies, as they now perceive taste, smell, and texture differently.”

She goes on to say that as children enter this stage of magical thinking, which lasts until around 7 to 8 years old, they tend to view food in binary terms–they either like it or they don’t, leaving little room for nuance. This stage often brings about food jags, where a child insists on eating the same foods repeatedly while avoiding others.

By the time they reach 8 to 9 years old, children transition into the stage of abstract thought. This allows for greater flexibility in their eating habits, making them more open to trying new foods and recognizing that their tastes may change over time, says Jeffcoat. 

The Role of Adults in Guiding Healthy Eating

The MyPlate program by the U.S. Department of Agriculture highlights the significant role adults play in shaping their family's eating habits by fostering a positive and structured mealtime environment. They suggest that establishing consistent routines and minimizing distractions, such as turning off the TV and putting phones away during dinner, helps create a focused setting where family members can engage with their food and each other. These small yet impactful changes contribute to a more mindful and enjoyable eating experience, reinforcing the importance of nutrition and family bonding.

Jeffcoat emphasizes that patience and consistency are key for parents as they navigate the various developmental stages of their child's eating habits. As children grow, their preferences and appetites fluctuate, making it essential for parents to provide structure without pressure.

Jeffcoat illustrates that a highly effective approach to feeding is the Division of Responsibility in Feeding (sDOR), a widely recognized model developed by Ellyn Satter, a respected dietitian and feeding specialist. This framework establishes clear roles where parents determine what, when, and where meals are served, while children maintain autonomy over how much they eat and whether they choose to eat at all.

The sDOR model promotes a balanced, stress-free approach to mealtimes by encouraging children to develop a healthy relationship with food at their own pace. By trusting children to listen to their own hunger and fullness cues, parents can help them build lifelong eating habits without resorting to coercion or control.

Additionally, this method reduces mealtime struggles and fosters a positive atmosphere where children feel empowered to explore new foods and flavors. Over time, it can lead to improved self-regulation, a more varied diet, and a greater appreciation for family mealtimes.

Creating a Positive Mealtime Environment

Providing structure is essential as children enter toddlerhood, helping them develop a sense of security and predictability around meals. According to Jeffcoat, setting consistent meal and snack times, eating together as a family, and introducing a variety of foods without pressure, bribing, or force are fundamental steps in fostering a healthy relationship with food. These steps ultimately lead to better self-regulation and healthier eating habits in the long run.

Research shows that children may need 12-15 exposures before accepting a new food, reinforcing the importance of persistence and patience. It’s natural for parents to feel discouraged when their child repeatedly rejects a new food, but continued, low-pressure exposure increases the likelihood of eventual acceptance.

One of the most effective ways to introduce new foods is through family meals, where children observe parents and siblings enjoying a variety of foods in a relaxed setting. This modeling behavior normalizes different textures, flavors, and colors, making unfamiliar foods seem less intimidating. Some children may be more hesitant or selective in their eating habits, but instead of labeling a child as “picky,” reframing their eating behavior as part of their unique sensory experience can help parents approach meals with greater empathy and patience.

There's no doubt eating is one of the most complex sensory experiences for children, involving taste, texture, smell, and even temperature. Recognizing this can help parents remain patient and supportive when their child struggles with new foods. PBS Kids suggests several engaging strategies to encourage food exploration, such as involving children in cooking, grocery shopping, or growing their own food.

Hands-on activities like stirring, washing vegetables, or choosing ingredients can make kids feel more invested in mealtime and increase their willingness to try new things. Additionally, keeping mealtimes lighthearted by incorporating storytelling, making food visually appealing, or using fun gadgets can turn trying new foods into an exciting adventure rather than a chore.

Jeffcoat also recommends hands-on food experiences beyond the dinner table. Visiting a farmer's market, planting a small garden, or creating food art can make food exploration more interactive and engaging. The goal is to foster a sense of curiosity and comfort with different foods in a fun and exciting way. “Ultimately, fostering a positive, pressure-free food environment allows children to develop healthy eating habits at their own pace, supporting both their physical and emotional well-being,” says Jeffcoat.

By embracing these strategies and understanding the natural phases of eating development, parents can guide their children through the ups and downs of food preferences while creating a joyful and healthy relationship with food that lasts a lifetime.

Conclusion

Navigating a child’s ever-changing food preferences can be challenging, but it's also a natural part of their development. Rather than viewing food phases as obstacles, parents can reframe them as opportunities to foster curiosity, patience, and a positive relationship with food.

Every child’s food journey is unique, and setbacks are a normal part of the process. What matters most is maintaining consistency, modeling healthy eating behaviors, and embracing the journey with empathy and flexibility.

With patience, persistence, and a focus on enjoyment rather than control, parents can help their children develop confidence in their food choices and an openness to trying new things. Over time, these efforts will minimize mealtime struggles and create a foundation for a lifetime of balanced and mindful eating.

The image featured at the top of this post is ©Volodymyr TVERDOKHLIB/Shutterstock.com